Rodriguez v. McDonnell Douglas Corporation

Rodriguez (plaintiff), a healthy 22-year-old apprentice sprinkler fitter, became triplegic after a 630-pound pipe fell on him while he worked on a hangar project for McDonnell Douglas (defendant) and other contractors. He required extensive surgeries and around-the-clock care from his wife for basic functions. At trial, an economist testified about his lost future earnings and lifelong care costs, and the jury awarded him over $4 million in general damages. The defendants appealed, arguing the award was so large it must reflect jury passion or prejudice.