Lawwly

Mel Frank Tool & Supply, Inc. v. Di-Chem Co.

Iowa Supreme Court

580 N.W.2d 802 (1998)

Relevant factsFree

Di-Chem Co. (defendant) leased property from Mel Frank Tool & Supply, Inc. (plaintiff) to store chemicals, including some deemed hazardous, under a lease requiring compliance with city ordinances; after the city amended its fire code to prohibit storing hazardous materials there, an inspection found violations, and Di-Chem told Mel Frank it would relocate. Mel Frank sued for the resulting lease obligations, and Di-Chem raised impossibility as a defense, but its own October letter and a representative's trial testimony both indicated only a portion, not all, of its chemical inventory was affected by the new ordinance; the trial court ruled for Mel Frank, and Di-Chem appealed.

IssueFree

Whether a party's performance under a lease can be excused when a law or ordinance restricts use of the premises but does not completely render the premises unusable by the party.

Unlock the full brief

Free accounts read 20 full briefs. No card required.

Related cases