Fletcher v. Rylands
Court of Exchequer
159 Eng. Rep. 737 (Ex. 1865)
Relevant factsFree
Fletcher (plaintiff) operated underground coal mines on land next to a reservoir Rylands (defendant) built to supply water to his mill. During construction, Rylands's engineers and contractors discovered the reservoir was being built over abandoned mine workings, though Rylands himself was unaware of this. After completion, the reservoir broke and flooded Fletcher's mines, and Fletcher sued Rylands for the resulting damage.
IssueFree
Whether a person is liable for damage he causes to the real property of another if his intent and actions are lawful and the damage was inadvertent.