United States v. Wulff
United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
758 F.2d 1121 (1985)
Wulff (defendant) was charged under the felony provision of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act for selling a federal agent a necklace made of protected bird parts; the felony provision, unlike the Act's separate misdemeanor provision, contained no requirement of guilty knowledge (scienter). The district court dismissed the felony indictment, holding a conviction under that scienter-free felony provision would violate Wulff's due process rights, and ruled that if convicted, Wulff should instead be sentenced under the misdemeanor provision; the government appealed.
Whether a criminal statute that lacks a guilty knowledge requirement violates the defendant's due process rights unless (1) the punishment is relatively small and (2) a conviction would not seriously damage the defendant's reputation.