Lawwly

State v. Turgeon

Washington Court of Appeals

120 Wash. App. 1050 (2004)

Relevant factsFree

Christopher Turgeon (defendant), leader of a group called "the Gatekeepers," believed God commanded him and another member, Applin, to kill a former member who had called Turgeon a false prophet; the two drove across state lines, wiped fingerprints from bullets, and interpreted a series of rainbows along the way as divine confirmation. Applin ultimately shot and killed the victim at his home while Turgeon acted as lookout. Both men were tried together and asserted an insanity defense based on a claimed command from God; the jury received a deific-decree insanity instruction and convicted both men, and Turgeon's appeal reached the Washington Supreme Court after the intermediate court affirmed.

IssueFree

Whether a trial court may instruct the jury that a defendant is legally insane if a delusion that God commanded the act destroyed the defendant's cognitive ability to distinguish right from wrong.

Unlock the full brief

Free accounts read 20 full briefs. No card required.