Lawwly

Sheldon v. Sill

United States Supreme Court

49 U.S. 441 (1850)

Relevant factsFree

Sill (plaintiff), a New York citizen, sued Sheldon (defendant), a Michigan citizen, on a bond and mortgage assigned to him by Hastings, also a Michigan citizen; Sheldon argued the Judiciary Act barred diversity jurisdiction over an assignee's claim unless the assignor could also have sued in federal court, which Hastings, sharing Michigan citizenship with Sheldon, could not have done.

IssueFree

Whether Congress has the authority to limit the jurisdiction of lower federal courts, as long as the acts of Congress do not conflict with the United States Constitution.

Unlock the full brief

Free accounts read 20 full briefs. No card required.