Industrial America, Inc. v. Fulton Industries, Inc.
Delaware Supreme Court
285 A.2d 412 (1971)
Industrial America (plaintiff), a merger broker, had unsuccessfully tried to arrange a merger for its client Bush Hog (B-H) with two other companies before B-H quietly decided to stop working with Industrial without telling it; Industrial then saw Fulton's (defendant) newspaper advertisement seeking a merger and promising to fully protect any broker who brought an opportunity, contacted Fulton about B-H, and Fulton expressed strong interest and asked Industrial to arrange a meeting. Fulton's president then independently contacted B-H directly and met with them without Industrial's knowledge, and B-H and Fulton continued negotiating on their own until completing their merger months later; Industrial sued both parties, won a broker's commission against B-H but lost against Fulton, with the trial court finding Industrial never accepted Fulton's advertised offer, and Industrial appealed the ruling against Fulton.
Whether an offeree's full performance of an act requested by an offeror in exchange for the offeror's promise constitutes sufficient acceptance to form a binding contract.