In re Phillip B.
California Court of Appeal
156 Cal. Rptr. 48 (1979)
Twelve-year-old Phillip B., who had Down syndrome and a congenital heart defect, lived in a residential care facility. Cardiac catheterization in 1977 revealed an extensive heart problem that his physicians said would cause an early death after progressive decline without surgery — surgery that would substantially increase his life expectancy but carried a 5-to-10 percent risk of death, plus a higher risk of post-operative complications, due to his Down syndrome and years without treatment. His parents refused to authorize the surgery, and a petition was brought under California law to make Phillip a dependent of the court solely to authorize the surgery; the court denied the petition, and an appeal followed.
Whether a court is justified in declining to make a minor a dependent of the court, against his parents' objection, in order to procure medical treatment that would greatly increase his life expectancy but also carry serious and potentially fatal risks.