Lawwly

Hyam v. Director of Public Prosecutions

House of Lords

[1974] 2 All E.R. 41

Relevant factsFree

Jealous over another woman marrying the man she loved, Hyam (defendant) poured gasoline through the woman's front-door mail slot and ignited it; the woman escaped with one child, but two other children died in the fire. Hyam was charged with two counts of murder and testified she never intended to kill anyone, only to frighten the woman into leaving the neighborhood; the trial judge instructed the jury that the necessary murderous intent existed if Hyam knew it was highly probable the fire would cause death or serious bodily harm, and the jury convicted her.

IssueFree

Whether a defendant who sets a fire with actual knowledge that death or serious bodily injury is highly probable, but who did not specifically intend to kill or injure anyone, possesses the intent required for a murder conviction rather than manslaughter.

Unlock the full brief

Free accounts read 20 full briefs. No card required.

Related cases