Fryer v. Kranz
South Dakota Supreme Court
616 N.W.2d 102 (2000)
Contractor Clint Kranz (defendant) employed Kathy Fryer (plaintiff) to clean tile floors using undiluted muriatic acid, despite the product's warning label -- unreadable when Fryer received it -- specifying dilution and exterior-only use; Kranz demonstrated by pouring the undiluted acid directly onto the interior floor, gave Fryer gloves and a small fan, but never warned her of the dangers despite having used the product before. Over four weeks of regular use, Fryer experienced nausea, light-headedness, and breathing difficulty, was eventually hospitalized, and sued Kranz for her ongoing injuries; Kranz moved for summary judgment arguing workers' compensation was her exclusive remedy, the trial court found a fact issue on whether Kranz committed an intentional tort, and Kranz appealed.
Whether an employer's reckless disregard for a known hazardous condition, without more, satisfies the substantial-certainty standard needed to take an employee's injury claim outside the exclusive remedy of workers' compensation.