Lawwly

Campbell v. Seaman

New York Court of Appeals

63 N.Y. 568 (1876)

Relevant factsFree

After landowners (plaintiffs) invested heavily in improving 40 acres with a mansion, ornamental trees, and gardens, their neighbor (defendant), who owned an inactive brickyard the landowners knew about but didn't know would be used for burning bricks, resumed brick-burning operations that released sulfuric acid gas, which drifted onto the landowners' property whenever the wind carried it there and killed their plants and trees over several years. The landowners objected before suing for an injunction and damages; the trial court granted both, and the neighbor appealed, arguing damages were adequate, the landowners had acquiesced to the nuisance, and he'd acquired a prescriptive right to burn bricks.

IssueFree

Whether a court may issue an injunction against a landowner's use of property that constitutes a nuisance causing substantial, irreparable injury to a neighboring property.

Unlock the full brief

Free accounts read 20 full briefs. No card required.

Related cases